MLS Cup Champion ×3
- 2023
- 2020
- 2008
Columbus Crew
Seasons2026
Supporters Shield Winner ×3
- 20082009
- 20072008
- 20032004
US Open Cup runner-up ×2
- 20092010
- 19971998
Leagues Cup Winner ×1
- 2024
Campeones Cup Winner ×1
- 2021
MLS Cup runner-up ×1
- 20142015
US Open Cup Winner ×1
- 2002
