Marcelo Andrés Herrera DR
Argentina 
Columbus Crew 
4 - 2
Toronto FC33'00
0 21 OCTColumbus Crew
0 - 0
St. Louis City SC7'00
0 18 OCTFC Cincinnati
0 - 2Columbus Crew90'00
0 10 OCTOrlando City
3 - 2Columbus Crew1'00
0 27 SEPColumbus Crew2 - 1
Inter Miami CF7'00
0 16 SEPColumbus Crew2 - 1Orlando City14'00
0 05 SEPColumbus Crew3 - 0
Colorado Rapids7'00
0 30 AUGColumbus Crew1 - 3
New England Revolution2'00
0 26 AUGClub America
2 - 0Columbus Crew2'00
0 19 AUGColumbus Crew1 - 2
Montreal Impact34'00
0 15 AUGCharlotte FC
3 - 1Columbus Crew19'00
0 24 MAYColumbus Crew2 - 0
Atlanta United12'00
0 20 MAYColumbus Crew1 - 0
New York City Football Club90'00
0 10 MAYNew York City Football Club3 - 0Columbus Crew90'00
0 29 APRColumbus Crew4 - 1
Knoxville troops87'00
0 25 APRColumbus Crew2 - 0
Philadelphia Union90'00
0 22 APRColumbus Crew2 - 1
Los Angeles Galaxy17'00
0 18 APRNew England Revolution2 - 1Columbus Crew23'00
0 15 APRRichmond Kickers
0 - 3Columbus Crew64'01
0 12 APRColumbus Crew1 - 1Orlando City61'00
0 