Hannes Wolf LW
Austria 
New York City Football Club 
2 - 1
Atlanta United89'00
0 24 OCTOrlando City
2 - 2New York City Football Club82'01
0 17 OCTNew York City Football Club1 - 1
Los Angeles FC90'00114 OCTInter Miami CF
2 - 0New York City Football Club32'00
0 10 OCTChicago Fire
2 - 1New York City Football Club82'10
0 26 SEPAtlanta United2 - 2New York City Football Club90'00
0 18 SEPNew York City Football Club0 - 1
New York Red Bulls62'00
0 12 SEPReal Salt Lake
0 - 2New York City Football Club88'00
0 09 SEPNew York City Football Club1 - 2
New England Revolution27'00
0 09 AUGCruz Azul
2 - 1New York City Football Club90'00
0 06 AUGNew York City Football Club2 - 0
Santos Laguna45'00
0 31 JULNew York City Football Club1 - 1
Toronto FC31'00
0 25 JULNew York City Football Club3 - 1Chicago Fire5'00
0 22 JULColumbus Crew
1 - 2New York City Football Club35'00
0 23 MAYNashville SC
2 - 1New York City Football Club24'00
0 20 MAYColumbus Crew
1 - 0New York City Football Club64'00
0 13 MAYCharlotte FC
0 - 1New York City Football Club90'01110 MAYNew York City Football Club3 - 0Columbus Crew85'30
0 03 MAYNew York City Football Club0 - 2
DC United27'00
0 22 APRNew York City Football Club4 - 4
FC Cincinnati72'00
0 